Clapton FC ground under threat

There are worrying developments at Clapton FC, whose Old Spotted Dog ground is immediately behind the Upton Lane pub. What follows is based on a recent article, taken from a website very concerned about the future of the club and ground. We offer our thanks and acknowledge their slightly edited, authorship: Two Hundred Percent

The Essex Senior League is eight divisions from the Premier League, but the world of its clubs is so far removed from the glamour and glitter of the elite that they may as well inhabit different universes. This is football as a hand-to-mouth existence, where players are seldom paid much more than expenses and clubs subsist on crowds that often fail to reach even three figures.

It is also a level at which clubs that have fallen upon hard times find themselves in. One such club is Clapton FC. Twice winners of the Isthmian League and five times winners of the FA Amateur Cup, Clapton have finished in the top half of any division of which they have been a member just twice since 1936.

So, winning might not be everything to them, but the club's on-going existence is under threat as a result of mismanagement and the threat is, perhaps unsurprisingly, related to the club's home ground, the Old Spotted Dog Ground.

The club signed a 100 year lease on the ground in 1992, through a company called Clapton Trust Limited, which was subsequently renamed as the Newham Community Leisure Trust Limited, in order to emphasis the difference between it and the football club. In the same year, it acquired charitable status.

The club's stand today, all too rarely filled

Vincent McBean was co-opted on to the board of NCLT on 8 January 2000, and he later also became Chief Executive of the football club, itself. NCLT was struck off by the registrar of companies for failure to file accounts in 2003, but the company continued to trade and in 2005 McBean wrote to the owners of the freehold of the ground, asking if he could buy it. The offer was rejected.

Two years later, the Charity Commissioner, having noted that NCLT had been struck off by Companies House, removed it from their register, because, in their view it had "ceased to exist". In 2008, however, Mr McBean successfully applied to the High Court to get NCLT re-instated at Companies House, but this reinstatement would come at a cost. The Trust was made to sign an undertaking not to trade or dispose of the lease. In 2009 it filed small business accounts, which meant that the company was reinstated.

The company filed no further accounts, and on 8 January this year Companies House wrote to the NCLT, giving them three months to show a reasonable cause as to why the company should not be struck off the register. It finally submitted a set on 13 March. They showed the Trust to have made a small trading loss for the year to 31 December 2011, of £2,700. Full details can be found here .

If the NCLT had been struck off, the lease of the Old Spotted Dog Ground would have been forfeited and if that had happened, it would have reverted to the freeholders, who have no legal obligation to offer a new lease to the club.

It is with this in mind that Friends of Clapton FC was formed (see above, for contact details), who have been in contact with Supporters' Direct, with the aim of getting the leasehold of the ground put into the fans' hands.

In the meantime, Clapton Football Club continues to subsist on the most threadbare of resources. The team, effectively, has to fund itself, which includes buying and washing its own kit, paying for their own match balls and travel, and it has even been suggested that players should be held responsible for their own fines.

Such circumstances hardly lend themselves to the signatures of the best players, so it is hardly surprising to see the Tons finish the season, just completed, at the foot of the Essex Senior League.

A match in April 1940, note packed stand

The NCLT has already overseen the club lose its Isthmian League status, which, having been one of the league's six founding members in 1901, it proudly hung onto for over a hundred years, before relegation in 2006. Its death would mean that only one of the original six that founded the Isthmian League - Civil Service FC - survive in its original state.

On a more positive note, a victory on the last day of the season saw the Tons lift themselves from the very bottom of the Essex Senior League, to finish 18th (out of 19), having recorded 3 victories, 12 draws and 21 defeats during the season. They finished the season with 21 points, with a goal scoring record of 37 for and 77 against.

Manager, Chris Woods commented:

We know that it wasn't the best season, but the club is on the up. We have great fans and players who are in it, together and they created a superb atmosphere. Tell your friends to 'Come along', because there is more life in the Old Spotted Dog, yet.

The Old Spotted Dog Ground, home to the club for 125 years, remains under threat with poor attendances and apparent lack of harmony and stability between many of those associated with the club. Maybe its true that Clapton FC doesn't mean a whole lot to many people, but it is a name that has been a part of the landscape of English football for more than a century. To lose it would be an upset for football in the country, and for the local community's heritage.

The apparent neglect accorded to both the pub and the football ground indicates either a huge amount of slackness by officials and owners alike, or some appreciation of the valuable real estate that would be freed up if the "inconvenience" of local heritage concerns could be overcome. We could not possibly comment.

Together - pub and club, under threat

We can, however, ask you to do whatever you can to help preserve these two vital pieces of Forest Gate heritage, unless, of course, you'd like to see a few more soulless buildings replace them.

Spotted Dog - still under threat

The Spotted Dog on Upton Lane, the oldest secular building in the borough, has been in a dreadful state of desolation and decrepitude ever since the night in June 2004, when the latest in a long line of landlords made his final call of "Time!" and so ended a tradition of hospitality stretching back over 500 years.

 

                              

                           Watercolour - FC Mears, 1932, courtesy Newham Archives





Enraged local residents and campaigners have formed a lobby group called "Save the Spotted Dog".  But will this be enough to preserve a unique part of our local heritage and a building of national historic significance?

In 1950 the government included the then-thriving public house in its National List of Buildings of Architectural or Historic Interest - one of only three entries accorded to the pre-Newham borough of West Ham. 

The earliest part of the timber-framed building, dating back to the decades between 1490 and 1510, is the central range comprising a two-bay hall, with an open crown post roof and a two-story cross wing also timber-framed to the east.  

The cross wing on the other side is slightly later; and the subsequent phases of the Georgian and Victorian periods (with some final additions in the 1960's) add to the interest of the building, by helping to tell a story that has lasted half a millennium.

Two-bay hall with open crown post roof

Indeed it was in the swinging sixties - on 25 September 1967 to be precise - that the Spotted Dog was recertified as a Grade ll listed building by the Department of the Environment. The official Reasons for Designation stating in part that it was:

a well-surviving, if simply constructed, late 15th century or early 16th century house (with an) interesting interior ... (and) ... particularly poignancy as a rare-surviving late-medieval building in this area, evoking the rural character that could be enjoyed here (before) this part of old Essex was lost to the expanding capital.

In fact it is the only surviving medieval domestic building in the borough and the third oldest after the Norman parish churches of East and West Ham.  The most authoritative source the Victoria History of the County of Essex (vol V1, p 51) - states that in the parish of West Ham: "it is likely that about 100 pre-17th century homes survived still in 1742.  By 1970 only one (i.e. The Spotted Dog) was known to survive."

1865 poster - showing extensive
 grounds and activities

It is little wonder that in his 1973 book Buildings in Newham the borough's former Director of Architecture and Planning, Kenneth Lund, felt it appropriate to "place on record (and) take account of the historic building stock remaining".  The Spotted Dog was of course included in the primary list of the ten local buildings of national significance.  These were, he said:

The best and last examples of a long building history.  Many are irreplaceable.  Old buildings form part of the memory of a community, serving to remind us all of who live in that area and how customs, life-styles and work functioned in the past.  They also provide an indication of the extent to which change has taken place and, in doing so, they give meaning to the present.

Back in 2004 a shift in the tastes of Newham's changing population and escalating local violence were cited as contributory factors in the closure of the pub.  Hopes of a speedy re-opening and the preservation of the unique corner of Forest Gate started to appear somewhat forlorn.  Local resident Bill Booth told the Forest Gate Times (April 2005) that he feared the worst when he spotted the pub's famous statute of Henry Vlll lying headless and discarded in a skip.

Undated print

But is there any justification to the claim that the pub was named the Spotted Dog because Henry Vlll kept his hunting pack kennelled there?  A careful review of the few available sources suggests that this traditional link is far less fanciful than might otherwise be supposed.

In his 1921 book: A New Book About London: a Quaint and Curious Volume of Forgotten Lore the prolific chronicler of the capital and its buildings, Leopold Wagner, writes of a:

huge barn-like structure in the vegetable garden ... (of the pub) ... wantonly sacrificed by the new proprietors in the interest of a bottling store ... (which had) ... anciently enclosed the kennels for a pack of royal hounds. 

He asserts that when Henry Vlll followed the chase in the Essex (Epping) Forest, he: "took up the hounds here at Upton" about a mile from the toll-gate which subsequently: "gave the name of Forest Gate to a new residential district."

1903 painting by H Smart (Newham Archives)

Some credence can be attached to this tale because having dissolved Stratford Langthorne Abbey in 1538 and seized all of its enormous land holdings in the borough Henry V111 used his own money to purchase the nearby Hamfrith Wood from its owner, Sir Anthony Hungerford - presumably to facilitate his love of hunting.

Mr Wagner provides some intriguing details in support of his account stating that what became the Spotted Dog was at the time the residence of Henry's Master of the Hounds, who was granted the privilege of taking personal profit for refreshing travellers passing that way. 

The author asserts that on this account up until the Great War the Spotted Dog "stood alone among the inns of the country at large in having its licence direct from the Crown," adding that:

Few historic hostelries ... have preserved their pristine freshness like Ye Olde Spotted Dog ... (its) ... picturesque, ivy-mantled wooden fabric ... appears very much today as when Daniel Defoe referred to it in his History of the Plague in London ... when ... (in 1665) ... those able to escape came to encamp in the fields round about, and again after the Great Fire the following year.

The isolated rural hamlet of Upton must suddenly have seemed like a medieval version of a giant gigantic refugee camp! In Mr Wagner's opinion: "the Spotted Dog is the most captivating 'house of call' in the environs of the Great City.

He describes a large painting (hanging on the west wall of the public bar) bearing the arms of the City Corporation and the date of 1603, and constituting a: "memorial of the meetings of merchant princes for eight years continuously while an earlier plague carried off thirty thousand souls."



1936 photograph - in better days

Corroboration of this part of Wagner's history is provided by Kenneth Lund, who writes:

Historically, the building is of considerable interest.  A plaque used to exist, showing the Arms of the City of London and the date 1603 ... to commemorate meetings which City merchants ... held in the pub during periods of plague.

It is incredible to think that 400 years ago we hosted the Stock Exchange here in Forest Gate!

But surely greater even than its historical importance is the building's unique significance as the last example we have of an ancient building history The story of Forest Gate and its constantly changing way of life is mirrored in the character of its buildings.  

In the earliest days communities were small and remote and  livelihoods which were based on the land.  Upton in particular took on a new identity with the arrival from the 1730s of families of entrepreneurial Quakers and East India Company people - and the already ancient Spotted Dog bore witness to their country retreats and extensive gardens.

1832 drawing, by Richenda Cunningham

Of course, it was in the Victorian era that the borough saw its most dramatic change with the arrival of the railways, the docks, and all manner of other industries. To service these vast new enterprises - and make a better life for themselves - over a quarter of a million people came to live in street upon terraced street.

Almost nothing was left of the fields, farms and country houses of earlier times, and since then much more has been lost, a process speeded up by the devastation of war and the consequent need to re-house in-comers and the homeless.


2004 - just before last orders

Currently Newham's mayor is presiding over what is referred to as a "supernova of regeneration exploding over the borough".  With so much that is new and such huge promises made for the future we are in danger of completely obliterating our past. 

What better reason could there be to try and Save the Spotted Dog?

Dereliction, 2007

Witness some of the neglect via this You Tube video: Spotted Dog 

authors: Lloyd Jeans and John Walker